When that bake sale sign-up sheet comes around, it’s easy to just write down “brownies” and call it a day.
But if you want to bring the dessert that everyone is talking about, there’s a simple answer: pie.
A homemade pie looks AMAZING on the table and is always one of the first things to sell out completely.
I put together a list of the absolute best pie recipes for any bake sale or fundraiser.
You’ll find classic fruit pies, creamy no-bake recipes, and even some fun and unique ideas you might not have thought of.
There’s something for every skill level, so it doesn’t matter if this is your first pie or your fiftieth.
So get ready to find a new go-to recipe that will have everyone asking for a slice.
1. Muffin Tin Mini Apple Pies (with Cookie Crust)
Muffin Tin Mini Apple Pies with Cookie Crust bring cozy apple pie flavor in a fun, handheld size.
Made with Granny Smith apples and a sweet brown sugar crust, they’re perfect for sharing or snacking.
2. Mini Sweet Potato Pies
Mini Sweet Potato Pies are a fall favorite with rich, spiced sweet potato filling and crisp graham cracker crusts.
Easy to make ahead and serve, they’re ideal for holidays or potlucks.
3. Blackberry Hand Pies
Blackberry Hand Pies deliver juicy, sweet-tart blackberry flavor in a flaky, easy-to-make pocket.
Perfect for dessert, snacks, or freezing for later enjoyment.
4. Mini Apple Pies
Mini Apple Pies baked in a muffin tin are a festive, bite-sized twist on classic apple pie.
With tender crust and warm apple flavor, they fit perfectly in any holiday spread.
5. Mini Key Lime Pies
Mini Key Lime Pies are tangy, creamy, and ready in under 30 minutes with a simple chill.
They’re a zesty, no-fuss treat that’s perfect for summer or any time of year.
6. Pumpkin Mousse Pie with Maple Cookie Crust – NO BAKE!
Pumpkin Mousse Pie with Maple Cookie Crust is a light, fluffy no-bake dessert packed with fall vibes.
Creamy layers and a sweet maple crust come together in a simple, crowd-pleasing treat.
7. Cannoli Pie – No Bake Recipe with Creamy Ricotta Filling
Cannoli Pie with Creamy Ricotta Filling is a no-bake dessert that tastes like a classic Sicilian treat.
Rich ricotta and cream cheese in a spiced, buttery crust make each bite unforgettable.
8. No Bake Lemon Icebox Pie Recipe
No Bake Lemon Icebox Pie delivers bright, zesty flavor with a smooth cream cheese base.
Tucked into a Golden Oreo cookie crust, it’s cool, creamy, and ready in just a few minutes.
9. Apple Pie with Graham Cracker Crust – Easy Recipe
This easy apple pie with graham cracker crust brings cozy fall flavors to your table in no time.
Packed with sweet apples and a buttery crumb topping, it’s a simple twist on a classic.
10. Chocolate Pumpkin Pie
Chocolate pumpkin pie gives you the rich taste of chocolate with the warm spice of pumpkin.
It’s perfect for anyone who loves both desserts in one bite.
11. Star Shaped Blueberry Hand Pies
Star shaped blueberry hand pies are fun, flaky, and full of juicy blueberries.
They’re perfect for summer gatherings, picnics, or kids’ parties.
12. Strawberry Hand Pies
Strawberry hand pies are a simple, sweet treat that’s great for summer outings.
Filled with fresh strawberries and baked in a flaky crust, they’re always a hit.
13. Cinnamon Roll Apple Pies – Easy 2-Ingredient Recipe
Cinnamon roll apple pies are a quick, no-fuss dessert made with just two ingredients.
Each bite brings the warmth of cinnamon, apples, and a soft, sweet crust.
14. Grilled Peach Pies
Grilled peach pies highlight the natural sweetness of grilled peaches in a lightly charred crust.
They’re drizzled with a simple glaze and perfect for peach season.
15. Mini Apple Pies
Mini apple pies are small, golden, and filled with cinnamon-sugar apples.
They’re quick to bake and ideal for sharing or enjoying as a tasty snack.
16. Mini Chocolate Cream Pies
Mini chocolate cream pies are rich, smooth, and individually sized for easy serving.
They’re elegant enough for holidays but simple enough for any sweet craving.
17. Mini Pecan Pies
Mini Pecan Pies are perfect for sharing at holiday gatherings with their sweet, rich filling and buttery crust.
Each bite-sized pie packs a punch of brown sugar and crunchy pecans for a delicious treat everyone will love.
18. Cranberry Hand Pies
Cranberry Hand Pies bring a sweet and tangy kick to your dessert table with juicy cranberry filling.
They’re easy to make and work well in the oven, fryer, or air fryer for quick holiday indulgence.
19. Mini Apple Pies
Mini Apple Pies are a cozy fall favorite that’s simple to make and always a hit at family events.
Serve them warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for a classic dessert combo.
20. Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pies
Chicken Pot Pie Hand Pies bring the comfort of a classic pot pie into a handheld, flaky package.
Each bite is filled with savory chicken, veggies, and creamy sauce—perfect for a satisfying meal on the go.
